Sunday, 25 December 2011

‘The Enchanted Island,’ a Baroque Mash-Up at the Met - NYTimes.com

The Met’s Gleeful Baroque Mash-Up

Nick Heavican/Metropolitan Opera

David Daniels and Joyce DiDonato in “The Enchanted Island,” a take on Shakespeare.


‘The Enchanted Island,’ a Baroque Mash-Up at the Met - NYTimes.com

Silent Night

in the style of John Cage.
Image originally posted on Facebook.

Feel free to sing along if you know it.
Happy holidays all, and Merry Christmas, if you keep it.

Silent Night

Opera Cake: We will barock you: L-Orlando, or Alexander Mørk-Eidem revisiting Handel's Orlando

Orlando, Komische Oper Berlin, December 21 2011



Director ..... Alexander Mørk-Eidem
Conductor ... Alessandro De Marchi

Orlando ..... Mariselle Martinez
Angelica ..... Brigitte Geller
Medoro ..... Susanne Kreusch
Dorinda ..... Ingrid Frøseth
Zoroastro ..... Andreas Wolf
Isabella, Zoroastro's Assistant ..... Bernd Stempel


Opera Cake: We will barock you: L-Orlando, or Alexander Mørk-Eidem revisiting Handel's Orlando

Friday, 23 December 2011

The Wagnerian: German Union DGB, criticizes Bayreuth's ticket pri...

I wasn't going to report this, instead I was going to leave it till I compiled an article on all of Bayreuth's new changes to ticket allocations. However, I came across a prominent  English language source that recently seemed to misrepresent what had taken place and thought it worth clarifying - or at least as well as my operatic German will allow.

Up until 2009 there were two so called "closed" performance at Bayreuth were tickets were allocated to  members of the German workers union DGB,  at heavily discounted prices. In 2009 this was dropped from two days to one. However, Bayreuth has now announced the end of  this remaining day and thus the end of  any discounted tickets to members of the DGB.

Toni Schmid, Chairman of the Board of Directors of the Festival, has stated that this is a result of criticisms made against the Festival regarding ticket allocation, following an investigation by the Bundesrechnungshof, the federal audit office (see my report on this here). She went onto to say that as a result of this Bayreuth must make more tickets available to the general public.

Unsurprisingly DGB, Chair Matthias Jena, has responded negatively to the announcement stating that the festival management is turning its back on its founders principles. Wagner, he said, intended the festival to be for the people not for the rich.

More as things develop.
The Wagnerian: German Union DGB, criticizes Bayreuth's ticket pri...: I wasn't going to report this, instead I was going to leave it till I compiled an article on all of Bayreuth's new changes to ticket allocat...

Thursday, 22 December 2011

CLASSICAL ICONOCLAST: Champagne and bombs - highs and lows of 2011

Champagne and bombs - highs and lows of 2011

What fizzed and what fell flat? Some real surprises and not quite what you'd expect. Safe top choice, Gounod Faust at the Royal Opera House. No compromise on the economic mess, top quality production, top quality singing. More adventurous top choice, Puccini Il Trittico, also ROH, and especially Suor Angelica. "ReNUNciation" - a Cinderella opera to the fore, great singing from Anna Larsson and Ermolena Jaho. Another mega hit, Mozart Don Giovanni at Teatro alla Scala, Milan. Fabulous singing, intelligent staging, provocative approach. When this comes out on DVD, get it.

Productions which help you re-assess wehat you think you knew are usually the most rewarding. We've all seen the same old production of Verdi La Traviata so many times, and Alfredo is almost always a lightweight. So when Piotr Beczala turned the role into a major creation, all assumptions overturned. It was like hearing the opera afresh, from a new perspective. This is a singer who really knows what he's doing and is genuinely well informed about historic tenor style. There is so much hype about these days, but Beczala is the genuine article, who delivers beautifully, without fuss.

For the same reason I loved Wagner Lohengrin from Bayreuth. Hans Neuenfels rats make you realize that the opera is about Brabant and why people want to control it. The rats are funny, tragic, scary, but more "human" than the main characters. It's a completely different perspective and once the shock value wears off, makes the opera much deeper emotionally and intellectually. Obviously we won't get rats again, but this production is seminal because it expands understanding,

For non-staged opera, Handel Alcina at the Barbican, conducted by Marc Minkowski, part of an excellent series there of operas on the theme of Orlando Furioso, which were very good, with specialist French casts and players., At the South Bank, Bartók's Duke Bluebeard's Castle. Tomlinson, DeYoung and Salonen showed how it should be heard and the semi staging showed how it can be seen. Probably way above the heads of those who don't relate to the quirkiness of this opera. At the ENO, Rameau's Castor and Pollux was also beyond those who couldn't see past the sex. Shocking, but not wrong. The whole point of the opera is that it's an allegory about the dangers of physical excess! So those who think it "must" be pretty because it's baroque need to study it and its period more carefully.

Popular opinion means nothing. Because Monty Python has many fans, most people loved Terry Gilliams's Berlioz Damnation of Faust for its cheap gags and irony-free racism.Unfortunately it proved Mel Brooks's adage about "Springtime for Hitler". People follow crowds when they don't think, in art as well as in politics. OTOH , I learned to love Rimsky-Korsakov's The Tsar's Bride at the Royal Opera House, not from the dull, lacklustre conducting by Mark Elder but from listening to Russian recordings afterwards, which bring out its true violent pungency. Then the mafia staging made total sense. Pity everyone else seemed to expect Sheherazade. Similarly, to my surprise, I actually got a kick from Mark-Anthony Turnage's Anna Nicole at the ROH despite the first act longeurs. Anna Nicole was hype, so the opera was a daring statement onn the dangers of trash, an irony lost on many.

On the other hand, 2011 saw other mega-hype bubbles burst (while some still grow). Both Havergal Brian and Mieczsyslaw Weinberg have been plagued for decades by "fans" who may not actually know their music but boost their own cachet by pretending to. Brian's Gothic Symphony received its best ever performance and highest profile at the Proms, but killed the myth. Similarly Weinberg's The Passenger (ENO) and The Portrait (Opera North) revealed the music for what it is. Fake fans went ballistic when their bluff was called. That's a good indicator of hype. Genuine music lovers can discuss things rationally. Fashion victims can't. Please see the comments under my post on Dudamel's Mahler at the Proms for more evidence. For much the same reasons, I didn't even bother with Nico Muhly's Two Boys, having spent 18 months trying desperately to make sense of his other music. My theory is that the Met wanted to outdo the ROH's coup in getting a new opera by a major British composer, so the Met invested huge money in creating Muhly. At least Turnage already existed and had a genuine track record.

This year I've done a lot less orchestral music, song and recordings than I used to (well over 400 a year, once). I loved Vladimir Jurowski's Liszt Faust Symphony at the Proms, and Andrew Davis's Elgar Caractacus at the Three Choirs Festival. Also Boulez Pli selon Pli, with Barbara Hannigan and Ensemble Intercontemporain, though it was the end of a long tour. Earlier performances must have been mind blowing! Although I've been doing Lieder for more than 40 years, most recitals this year were good rather than exceptional, and there were a few disappointments. A quiet patch, maybe. Recordings-wise, I loved José Serebrier's Dvořák Symphony no 9 "The New World", vindicating studio performance as an art form. Best CD of the year, though, has got to be Pierre Boulez's CD of Szymanowski's Symphony no 3 with the Wiener Philharmoniker. This is so astonishing, it ranks among my top favourites of all time. If you think you know Boulez, or if you think you know Szymanowski, listen to this. It's a revelation. Boulez is conducting two concerts at the Barbican next year, one in April with Tetzlaff and Scriabin, the other in May with Znaider and Szymanowski 3. I booked a year ago.


CLASSICAL ICONOCLAST: Champagne and bombs - highs and lows of 2011: What fizzed and what fell flat? Some real surprises and not quite what you'd expect. Safe top choice, Gounod Faust at the Royal Opera House ...

Wednesday, 21 December 2011

Die Meistersinger at the Royal Opera House - with photos - Intermezzo

Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg - Royal Opera House, 19 December 2011 (first night)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0341 PRODUCTION IMAGE (C) BARDA (800x471)

The scene above is the most imaginative one in a production that otherwise sticks doggedly to the letter of the text. As midsummer madness or Wahn grips the Nuremburgers at the end of Act II, the featureless walls are suddenly pocked with openings. Bodies froth out from high, low, and even above the stage. The boundaries are breached; the city can no longer contain the human activity within. It's subtler than it looks.

Graham Vick's ageing production may look a little tired these days, but it's still one of the best of the ROH's variable Wagner stable. Even if it leans more heavily on the tradition the opera challenges rather than the creativity it seeks to encourage, it doesn't ignore the underlying themes altogether. And at least the laughs come in the right places. The holiday season brings a lot of first-time operagoers into the house. They'll get a lucid introduction to what for many is a forbidding opera (and composer). But it's in no way dumbed-down. Take away the pseudo-authentic costumes (and the codpieces - please) and what you have are bare, generic sets and a clearly-characterised drama, where the often vast forces are marshalled with expert and telling detail that never slips into fussiness.

Pappano created an equally fluid narrative from the score, though a lack of clarity in his contouring sometimes lent a curious backing track-effect. Whenever he's in the pit, he energises the orchestra magnificently, and they play with real passion and commitment. But this work needs more than that - specifically, a bit more air than he gave it. Hopefully the interpretation will develop as the run progresses.

No Wagner cast is ever quite up to the job - the world ran out of Birgit Nilssons long ago - but this one does a pretty good job. Toby Spence was outstanding as David, a role I first saw him play in Edinburgh a few years ago. His interpretation has matured and everything was perfect - the enthusiasm, the deference, the eagerness to please. He coloured the words as if every single one mattered. John Tomlinson too had a terrific night, cunningly working the natural ageing of his voice into his befuddled and slightly doddery Pogner.

Emma Bell made a vibrant Eva, but her dark tone and often thrilling power lend her a knowing quality that's not quite right. If the world needs saving from Nadja Michael, Emma Bell's the woman to do it - I'd love to hear her in a more dramatic role.

I wasn't keen on Simon O'Neill's Walther at all. He has an almighty pair of lungs, but sounds pinched and nasal in the register where most of this part lies. If you want to hear how it should be done, check out the Bayreuth Meistersinger DVD (Katharina Wagner's much-derided production) for the Klaus Florian Vogt version.

There was a jarring hint of the Graham Nortons in Peter Coleman-Wright's Beckmesser, and a bit too much approximation in the vocal line of an otherwise polished performance.

Which leaves us with the nominal centre of the work, Hans Sachs. I've actually seen Wolfgang Koch several times in German productions, but never felt moved to write about him. Why? He generally sings, as he did last night, quite beautifully and appropriately, without strain or apparent effort. And he doesn't lack stage presence. But there's an anonymous quality to every performance of his I've seen, a lack of generosity.

Close-up, as I was last night, his acting skills compensated. What's not in the voice is there in the face. He's very highly rated by some people whose opinions I seriously respect, so perhaps I've just been unlucky in the few performances I've caught - and to be fair, he did at least start to catch fire towards the end. But on the basis of what I saw last night, he needs to give more of himself to flesh out the part.

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0009 BELL AS EVA, O'NEILL AS WALTHER (C) BARDA (800x516)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0012 BELL AS EVA, SHIPP AS MAGDALENE (C) BARDA (734x800)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0029 SPENCE AS DAVID (C) BARDA (572x800)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0055 SPENCE AS DAVID, O'NEILL AS WALTHER AND APPRENTICES (C) BARDA (800x513)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_062 COLEMAN-WRIGHT AS BECKMESSER, TOMLINSON AS POGNER (C) BARDA (800x554)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0098 TOMLINSON AS POGNER (C) BARDA (623x800)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0122 SEE PHOTOGRAPHS LIST FOR CREDIT INFORMATION (C) BARDA (800x474)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0141 COLEMAN-WRIGHT AS BECKMESSER (C) BARDA (500x800)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0173 SEE PHOTOGRAPHS LIST FOR CAPTION INFORMATION (C) BARDA (800x453)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0175 APPRENTICES (C) BARDA (800x613)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0190 BELL AS EVA AND TOMLINSON AS POGNER (C) BARDA (800x742)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0241 BELL AS EVA, KOCH AS HANS SACHS (C) BARDA (605x800)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0265 LLOYD AS NIGHTWATCHMAN (C) BARDA (539x800)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0306 KOCH AS HANS SACHS AND COLEMAN-WRIGHT AS BECKMESSER (C) BARDA (800x585)


MEISTERSINGER 111216_0387 KOCH AS HANS SACHS (C) BARDA (800x538)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0419 KOCH AS HANS SACHS, O'NEILL AS WALTHER (C) BARDA (800x618)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0517 SEE PHOTOGRAOHS LIST FOR CAPTION INFORMATION (C) BARDA (800x497)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0613 KOCH AS HANS SACHS (C) BARDA (800x532)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0629 COLEMAN-WRIGHT AS BECKMESSER (C) BARDA (683x800)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0659 O'NEILL AS WALTHER, BELL AS EVA (C) BARDA (627x800)

MEISTERSINGER 111216_0680 KOCH AS HANS SACHS, BELL AS EVA, O'NEILL AS WALTHER (C) BARDA (800x566)

production photos (above): Clive Barda

curtain call photos (below): intermezzo.typepad.com

Meistersinger first roh 191211 001 (640x471)


Meistersinger first roh 191211 011 (640x480)


Meistersinger first roh 191211 015 (640x480)


Meistersinger first roh 191211 016 (640x480)


Meistersinger first roh 191211 019 (627x640)


Meistersinger first roh 191211 025 (640x419)


Meistersinger first roh 191211 026 (640x438)


Meistersinger first roh 191211 028 (640x477)


Die Meistersinger at the Royal Opera House - with photos - Intermezzo

Tuesday, 20 December 2011

Boulezian: Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg, Royal Opera, 19 December 2011

Royal Opera House, Covent Garden

Hans Sachs – Wolfgang Koch
Walther von Stolzing – Simon O’Neill
Eva – Emma Bell
Sixtus Beckmesser – Peter Coleman-Wright
Veit Pogner – Sir John Tomlinson
David – Toby Spence
Magdalene – Heather Shipp
Kunz Vogelsang – Colin Judson
Konrad Nachtigall – Nicholas Folwell
Fritz Kothner – Donald Maxwell
Hermann Ortel – Jihoon Kim
Balthazar Zorn – Martyn Hill
Augustin Moser – Pablo Bemsch
Ulrich Eisslinger – Andrew Rees
Hans Foltz – Jeremy White
Hans Schwarz – Richard Wiegold
Nightwatchman – Robert Lloyd

Graham Vick (director)
Elaine Kidd (revival director)
Richard Hudson (designs)
Wolfgang Göbbel (lighting)
Ron Howell (movement)

Royal Opera Chorus (chorus master: Renato Balsadonna)
Orchestra of the Royal Opera House
Antonio Pappano (conductor)

Hans Sachs would be the first to counsel us of the dangers of extolling past achievements at the expense of the present. It is an apt warning in the case of Wagner, for whom great performances, whether recorded or in the theatre, sear themselves with into the memory with perhaps unusual tenacity, acting as Mastersinger-guardians of the imagination. That said, whilst we should all beware the tendency to act as Beckmesser or worse, not every newcomer proves to be a Stolzing. At a time of year when some midsummer warmth, even magic, could hardly be more welcome, glad tidings were, sadly, thin onstage or in the pit.

Walther (Simon O'Neill), Eva (Emma Bell), congregation
This Marker has fond memories of Graham Vick’s production. It was the first he saw in the theatre, in 2000 and again in 2002; it seemed so full of joy and good humour; above all, it provided a seemingly perfect backdrop for the unforgettable greatness of Bernard Haitink’s conducting. (Mark Wigglesworth was far from put to shame in 2002.) Now, alas, it looks tired: there are few cases of production styles failing to date; in this, as in so much else, Patrice Chéreau’s Ring offers a near-miraculous exception. The evocation of Nuremberg in Richard Hudson’s sets seems as much of its time as John Major’s ‘Back to Basics’ (not that David Cameron seems to have noticed). Where once one saw Breugel, now one registers the lack of darkness in a work every bit as Schopenhauerian as Tristan und Isolde. What once was joyous now seems evasive. The ‘amusing’ antics of the apprentices now merely irritate. Time has passed, yes, but a good part of the problem seems to be the revival direction. Perhaps matters would have been different had Vick himself returned, but there seems to be precious little to Elaine Kidd’s direction beyond having singers don their costumes and sing: it resembles a repertory production in a provincial house rather than a performance on one of the world’s great stages. Oddly, the chorus often seems better directed than the singers. As for the codpieces, it would be an act of charity for all concerned to consign them to the dustbin of history.


Beckmesser (Peter Coleman-Wright) attempting to sing the Prize Song
 The contrast becomes all the more glaring, however, when one turns to the Old Master, Haitink. Though Tristan was his final production as Music Director of the Royal Opera, he chose the final scenes of Die Meistersinger as the culmination of his gala farewell to Covent Garden. Indeed, there is perhaps no opera more strongly associated with him. It was a great privilege to receive one’s theatrical baptism from him, though Christian Thielemann at Bayreuth, just a few months later in 2000, also lingers in the memory. Where, under Haitink, the Orchestra of the Royal Opera House sounded every inch a rival to Bayreuth, Vienna, or Dresden, here too much was lacklustre. The horns too often found themselves all over the place; woodwind were untidy; strings and brass lacked bloom. More seriously, Antonio Pappano’s direction failed to probe. Where every line should not only glow but take its place in vital counterpoint with every other, the work emerging almost as if an enormous Bach fugue, this reading remained very much on surface. The Prelude to the first act lacked any distinguishing feature beyond a strangely prominent tuba line: that extraordinary moment of recapitulatory arrival, heralded by adorable triangle, went for nothing. It is not a matter of speed as such, for the act managed both to sound hard-driven and well-nigh interminable. To follow and to guide the Wagnerian melos is no easy task, but when one has heard Haitink, or Thielemann for that matter, Wagner as soft-focus Verdi will not pass muster. There were better passages: the music following ‘Merkwürd’ger Fall!’ was nicely characterised, though it did not arise as it should from what had gone before, nor did it lead where it must. Even the third act, better in a good few respects, suffered from a Prelude that was merely slow: again, speed, or lack thereof, does not equal profundity. The strings now played beautifully, but it was the wrong kind of beauty, the shimmering more akin to the third act of La traviata. The closing bars were not, admittedly, helped by premature applause – surely the music is loud enough to enable one to hear when it has finished – but Pappano harried them so as to sound inconsequential; I have never heard the final chord register in so perfunctory a fashion.

Apprentices, David (Toby Spence), Walther
Save for a generally strong performance from the chorus – as usual, Renato Balsadonna had both learned and conveyed his lessons well – and from Toby Spence as David, there was little vocally to lift the spirits. Even Spence had the occasional moment of crooning, but his was otherwise an alert, carefully shaded reading, which married tone and word as his character outlines. The contrast with Simon O’Neill’s Walther was, to put it mildly, stark, nowhere more so than in the Quintet, where O’Neill stood out like a pneumatic drill. The unpleasant, metallic sound of his voice rendered the Prize Song more of a trial song – and for the first time made me think the naysayers might have it right: do we simply hear that music too often? You do not have to be Sándor Kónya, but it undeniably helps. Where Spence used, indeed relished, Wagner’s language, O’Neill seemed uncertain as to what it meant; maybe the words were not learned by rote, but that was how it sounded. Emma Bell’s intonation was variable as Eva: again, the beginning of the quintet was a glaring casualty. Too often, her delivery was blowsy; the best one could say was that she looked good in a white dress. Peter Coleman-Wright’s Beckmesser sounded and often looked over the hill: a comparison with Sir Thomas Allen for Haitink goes beyond unfortunate. Even Sir John Tomlinson, who sang Sachs in 2000, was out of sorts, loud and yet threadbare as Pogner. This was an instance too far of all-purpose raving and bluster: it was as if Bluebeard, or at a pinch, Wotan, had wandered in from another performance entirely. Wolfgang Koch was a musical, verbally attentive Sachs, but his voice sounded at least one degree too small for the theatre. Midsummer, as so often in this country, was postponed until another year. 
Boulezian: Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg, Royal Opera, 19 December 2011